Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I find your last paragraph confusing. "If you think the military is awful, sign up!" Why would anyone ever do that?


> "If you think the military is awful, sign up!" Why would anyone ever do that?

So they could prove it for themselves, and be able to explain from a position of authority as to why the military is awful.

My experience from the military was far different than what I expected and that's despite having lived my entire childhood with a father who had joined the same Navy I did.

If nothing else it helps to understand better that thing you are criticizing, just like we don't typically hold a lot of respect for MBAs with no tech background who think that coding is easy, programmers are replaceable cogs and IT is just a cost center.


I value not being placed in a position where I have to follow orders or go to prison above adding credibility to my criticisms. I can't understand why you might think it would be the other way around.


> I value not being placed in a position where I have to follow orders or go to prison above adding credibility to my criticisms.

Fair enough, just don't be surprised when people properly reject your uninformed opinions about something that you know little to nothing about.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: